Compel Groupgroup

Gigabit and PoE Network Switches

Author: James Whitfield, Equipment Desk5 min read
Updated

Three numbers describe a switch: how many ports, how fast they are, and how much power it can deliver over them. The third is the one people get wrong, because a switch quoted as supplying thirty watts a port almost never supplies that on every port at once. The total power budget is the real limit.

12 products from £160.99 to £326.99

Specs and prices

Specifications as declared by the seller of each listing, not our own measurements. Prices update with the catalogue.

ProductPriceApplicationMaterial
Front and side view of 8-Port 2.5G Managed Switch showing eight Ethernet and two SFP+ ports.8-Port 2.5G Managed Switch£232.99NAS / WiFi 6 AP / Home Lab / Small OfficeMetal
Front panel of 8 Port 2.5G Network Switch showing eight RJ45 ports and two SFP+ uplink slots.8 Port 2.5G Network Switch£232.99NAS / Home Lab / Office Network / Wi-Fi APMetal

The power budget, not the per port figure

Power over Ethernet comes in tiers. The original standard delivers around 15 watts at the port, PoE+ around 30, and the newer higher power standards considerably more. A device datasheet tells you which tier it needs, and a switch that only offers the lowest tier will not run a camera that expects the middle one.

The figure that constrains a real installation is the total budget. A switch with eight PoE ports and a 120 watt budget cannot give 30 watts to all eight at once, and what happens when you try is that the switch sheds ports, usually the highest numbered ones, often intermittently as devices draw more at night when infrared illuminators come on.

So add up what the devices actually draw, add headroom, and compare that against the budget rather than the per port figure. Cameras with heaters and pan units are the ones that catch people out, because their idle draw is a fraction of their peak.

Reading a PoE specification
FigureMeansWatch for
Per port wattsMaximum one port can deliverNot available on all ports at once
Total power budgetWhat the switch can supply in totalThis is the real limit
PoE standardWhich tier of powered device it runsA device needing a higher tier will not start
Number of PoE portsHow many can deliver powerOften fewer than the total port count

Unmanaged, or worth paying for management

An unmanaged switch has no configuration. Plug things in and they talk. For a small office, a workshop or a handful of cameras that is the right answer, because there is nothing to set up and nothing to misconfigure.

A managed switch adds the ability to separate traffic into VLANs, to prioritise some traffic over other traffic, to see which port is doing what, and to turn a PoE port off and on remotely. That last one is quietly the most useful feature in a camera installation, because it reboots a hung device without anyone climbing a ladder.

The middle ground, sometimes called smart or web managed, gives VLANs and basic monitoring through a browser without the depth of a full managed switch. For most small installations that is the sensible upgrade point: buy it when you need VLANs or remote port control, not before.

Port speed, uplinks and where the bottleneck sits

Gigabit on every port is the baseline now and is more than enough for cameras, terminals and general office traffic. The bottleneck in a real network is rarely the access port; it is the single link carrying everything back to the router or the next switch.

That is what uplink ports are for. A switch with 2.5 gigabit or 10 gigabit uplinks lets a stack of gigabit devices share a fatter pipe upstream, and it is worth having wherever one switch feeds another rather than sitting at the end of the chain.

Fibre uplink cages appear on many switches and solve a different problem: distance. Copper Ethernet is limited to 100 metres, so a run between buildings or down a long yard needs fibre, and a switch with an SFP cage at each end is the straightforward way to do it.

Industrial switches and where they earn their price

An industrial switch looks expensive next to a desktop one until you read what it is built for. DIN rail mounting, a wide operating temperature range, dual redundant DC power inputs and no fan are the usual differences, and each of them addresses a way ordinary switches fail in a cabinet or outdoors.

Temperature is the common killer. A plastic desktop switch in a roadside cabinet or a plant room sees temperatures well outside what it was designed for, and it does not fail cleanly; it becomes intermittent, which is far harder to diagnose than a dead unit.

The fanless design matters for a second reason. A fan pulls dust and moisture through the housing, so in a workshop or a dusty plant a fanless switch simply lasts longer. Where a switch lives in a clean office, none of this is worth paying for.

James Whitfield, Equipment Desk editor at Compel GroupJames WhitfieldEquipment Desk

James edits the machine and equipment buying guides. The specifications on these pages are the declared figures from the live listings we hold, with a note wherever a number comes from a published standard instead. Pages are re-checked as the catalogue changes.

Share
Add Compel Group as a preferred source on Google

Buying guide

Gigabit and PoE Network Switches questions

Can a PoE switch power every port at its full rating?
Usually not. The total power budget is the real limit, and it is often well below the per port figure multiplied by the number of ports. Add up your actual device draw with headroom and compare against the budget.
Do I need a managed switch?
Only if you need VLANs to separate traffic, traffic prioritisation, port monitoring, or the ability to power cycle a PoE port remotely. That last feature reboots a hung camera without a ladder, which is often what tips the decision.
What are uplink ports for?
They carry the combined traffic of the switch to the next device. Faster uplinks stop a single link becoming the bottleneck when a stack of gigabit ports all feed upstream through one cable.
How do I connect two buildings?
With fibre. Copper Ethernet is limited to 100 metres, so a longer run needs a switch with an SFP cage at each end and a fibre link between them.
Why do my cameras drop out at night?
Often the PoE budget. Infrared illuminators and heaters raise the draw after dark, and a switch at its power limit sheds ports. Compare peak device draw rather than idle draw against the switch budget.
Is an industrial switch worth the extra?
In a cabinet, plant room or anywhere outside a clean office, yes. Wide temperature range, redundant DC inputs and fanless construction address the specific ways desktop switches fail, usually by becoming intermittent rather than dying.

We use cookies. Some keep the store working, others show us what to fix. No third-party trackers, and we never sell your data. Learn more about cookies and your privacy